Workers' Weekly On-Line
Volume 56 Number 34, November 21, 2026 ARCHIVE HOME JBCENTRE SUBSCRIBE

Youth Have the Future in their Hands

Incoherence of Government's Proposals to Solve NEETs Crisis

Incoherence of Government's Proposals to Solve NEETs Crisis

Alan Milburn, the former Labour Health Secretary under Tony Blair, released his final report on November 17 on what the current Labour government defines to be the problem of young people not in employment, education or training (NEETs). "Young people" here refers to those who are aged 16 to 24. The gist of Milburn's report, entitled "From a Welfare State to a Working State", is that Britain faces a crisis because the young people who are not in employment, education or training number almost a million, and that Britain "is at risk of losing a generation of young people" [1].

On schools, the report says that they should be judged on their pupils' work-readiness and made to identify those at risk of becoming "NEET". The report's recommendations for schools include judging schools on their pupils' work-readiness by 2028, creating a new 14 to 19 framework, and new writing, numeracy and oracy checks at key stage 3. It also includes new targets, with 90 per cent of pupils expected to be "school ready", and 90 per cent achieving the expected standard at the end of primary school, by 2036. According to Milburn, work experience should become a statutory duty, while all schools including primaries should be required to use data to identify and support pupils at risk of becoming NEET [2].

Speaking in the House of Commons the same day, Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, said that this crisis "creates a human cost that no country should ask its young people to bear". He told MPs, "It robs them of the thing that is most important to their lives: the prospect of a good future, and it demands a response that is much more than a conventional departmental response." [3]

However, the Milburn report does not suggest the remedy of the government's ensuring a future for the youth, either by investing in creating that future through all-round education, through putting the young people at the centre of considerations in setting the direction of the economy, or most importantly through empowering the youth to participate in shaping that future. At this point the social wealth created by working people is not being directed at shaping a society in which the future of the youth is cared for. Rather it is siphoned off by the billionaires and trillionaires who extract it from the economy.

Even a brief look at the relatively recent history of what are being called NEETs will show that the rights of the youth to employment and to education and training have not been recognised or guaranteed. The 1970s saw the social welfare state going into crisis. Throughout this period, youth unemployment rose sharply. Then unemployment rose dramatically in the 1980s also, as neoliberalism took hold, and broadly speaking the youth were encouraged to fend for themselves in the so-called "labour market". The period of New Labour in power saw reducing the numbers of NEETs as a policy objective, and the mantra of "education, education, education" become a smokescreen for an actual crisis in education and training. Precarious work became a phenomenon, while the youth have been resisting the attacks on their education, and resisting their disempowerment, social exclusion, the problem of homelessness, and the trend towards war.

Rather than recognising that the "NEETs" crisis is not an anomaly and taking steps to urgently change the direction of the economy and invest social wealth to the benefit of individuals, collectives and society as a whole, the Burnham government has come up with a "10-year project", framing the NEETs situation as a "moral crisis". It is laughable that while talking of this "moral crisis", the aim is said to be that of reducing the NEET rate to around five per cent by 2036, which Alan Milburn called "an effective rate of NEET Zero". It is as if the cartel parties were trying to make a mockery of the critical situation facing the youth.

Shall we see the increased onus on the "public sector" to lead the way when it comes to maximising opportunities for the young? Are the relatively minor changes going to provide incentives for the "private sector" to step in and realise the "NEET Zero"? The issue is that the interests of the youth and their empowerment are not being put at the centre of considerations. Instead, as commentators have been pointing out, many young people could lose social security support through the measures, while substantial subsidies are to be provided to employers, with no thought of the long-term consequences or the type of work which will benefit the 16-24-year-olds, not to speak of the interests of society. The rights of the young, in short, are not being guaranteed; nor is the issue of full employment nor the necessary support for all young people, and indeed working people as a whole, being aimed at. The root causes of the "NEETs crisis" are being ignored, and the support for vulnerable youth, the lack of which is so much part of this crisis, is being downplayed.

It is not for the youth to fit in with the aims of the oligarchs and the cartel parties which reflect their outlook. A transformation is needed and the demands and interests of the youth must be directly served.

The youth and young workers are taking steps to voice their interests and demand a society in which they are in control of their own lives. They are also demanding an end to war preparations, the war machine and the gearing of "solutions" to the advantage of weapons manufacturers.

The youth have the future in their hands!

Response of teaching unions

An article in Schools Week reported on the response of the teaching unions:

Pepe Di'Iasio, general secretary of ASCL, said his organisation supported the focus on vocational and technical education, as well as work experience and careers guidance. But it was "disappointing to see how quickly the report defaults to the usual mishmash of targets, tests, and new accountability measures which are a hallmark of many other reports over recent years". He said the ready-for-work standard "will create yet more pressure on a system which is already overwhelmed with expectations and which is simply not resourced to deliver a whole new tier of requirements". He continued, "If the government intends to do this then it must come up with a realistic plan and the funding to enable schools to deliver this expectation." The union will be "calling on ministers to ensure that the implementation of any new changes is assessed against the funding and workforce capacity required to deliver them." Di'lasio added that the key stage 3 writing, numeracy and oracy check "will detract from curriculum time in already overcrowded timetables" and that there needs to be a "practical plan" to meet the raised key stage 2 attainment targets, given how they are affected by wider socio-economic challenges.

Paul Whiteman, general secretary at NAHT, said: "Schools will also wonder how 'work readiness' would be defined and measured. Schools do not need another accountability measure judged by Ofsted at a time when they already have serious concerns about school inspection." He added that this, and the use of destination data, "also risk partly judging schools on factors beyond their control", such as local labour markets. Whiteman added that while earlier identification of at-risk pupils would be helpful, "schools would be concerned if this was used primarily as a monitoring, reporting or accountability tool". Whiteman acknowledged that some of the ambitions were "laudable", but that school leaders will wonder how they will be achieved, especially with ongoing reforms to the curriculum, SEND and enrichment. He added that plans for 90 per cent of pupils to be school ready, and for 90 per cent to meet the expected standard in key stage 2, would require "significant investment" from government. Whiteman warned that the checks "should be genuinely diagnostic rather than high stake assessments", that ministers would need to explain how they would create more flexibility "within an already crowded curriculum" at key stage 3. Whiteman added that it "will also require employer capacity to be addressed and must not impose extra unfunded administrative burdens upon schools".

Leora Cruddas, chief executive of the Confederation of School Trusts, said they were concerned about the proposals. "We should be cautious of over-emphasising the role of schools and underplaying the economic arguments around the number of young people not in education, employment or training." Cruddas said CST was also cautious about primary schools being told to use NEET indicator tools. "The best thing that we can do is focus on ensuring that more children can read and write to an expected standard."

Daniel Kebede, general secretary of the National Education Union, welcomed a proposal for less GCSE exams and freeing up 10 per cent of the key stage 3 from the national curriculum. "But Milburn's prescriptions for schools contradict his diagnosis, with more tests and targets: a statutory key stage 3 check on top of the Year 8 reading test, and a ready-for-work rate and destination measure for Ofsted to inspect. Whatever Milburn intends, statutory tests become high stakes: schools chase the metric, not learning, and more pupils disengage." Kebede said that "large employers should have to offer placements" if schools have a statutory requirement to offer work experience.

Notes

[1] "From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation", DWP, November 17, 2026

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/from-a-welfare-state-to-a-working-state-a-new-settlement-for-the-next-generation/from-a-welfare-state-to-a-working-state-a-new-settlement-for-the-next-generation

[2] See full report pdf: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6afb1fc5ccb3ea58ac8743c1/from-a-welfare-state-to-a-working-state-full-report.pdf

[3] "Milburn Review: Final Report", Hansard, November 17, 2026

https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2026-11-17/debates/3A423B53-86A8-44D6-9C28-671C893A9434/MilburnReviewFinalReport


Link to Full Issue of Workers' Weekly

RCPB(ML) Home Page

Workers' Weekly Online Archive